A couple of quick comments from the peanut gallery:
Safford - I would go with the younger Andrews but like SS, ridiculous pool of talent to choose from
Sunnyside - Having watched and coached and competed against them since 1982 (granted, not as much these past few years)...I have to go with Eric Larkin but jeez there are tons to choose from!
Santa Cruz - definitely Willie Paul Maxwell - 4x Champ
Benson - Fenn (4x) although Goodwin certainly tempts the vote
Buena - Don (JR) Frye - hands down
Apache Junction - really difficult, any of the McMinns or the beast, Danny Faqir, but probably RobRoy or Wayne
Camp Verde - Ryan Allred
Mingus - I am getting old...I think the kid who placed 3rd at Senior Nationals at about 160 lbs in about '96 would be my choice
Willcox - Justin Rockhill or Ben Miller
Flowing Wells - Kyle Kotchau (sp?) Tons to choose from here from the '70's and '80s
Douglas - back in the day, they produced some awesome wrestlers and I would go with Julio Moreno (2x, OW)
Nogales - Brad or Scott Beach
Rio Rico - Villaescusa
What about Flag, Coconino, Winslow, Round Valley, Tuba, Page, Snowflake?
Thanks for the post - very cool to see a bunch of names on here and such diversity. I am a little dated so pardon the throwbacks :,)